TSO investors: Lawsuit in the USA or in Germany?

Image source: tampatra

Many German investors have invested in US real estate projects through limited partnerships, including numerous investors in the TSO projects. I am currently working with investors from the American TSO group. In this context, questions have arisen regarding a possible place of jurisdiction for lawsuits.

Because if there are no distributions from an investment in a US real estate fund, or if there are questions about reports or the use of investors’ funds, sooner or later the question of enforcing claims arises.

I explain the problem in this example as follows:

Where are opponents and wealth located?

When participating in a US project, the opposing parties, their accounts and their real estate are usually located in the USA. These are the general partner, the project company, and the companies associated with them. A judgment is only as valuable as it can be enforced. Enforcement takes place where the assets are located.

What to consider when filing a lawsuit in Germany

A lawsuit before a German court is not excluded. The Brussels jurisdiction rules of the EU do not apply to defendants based in the USA. International jurisdiction is determined by the ZPO. In practice, it is primarily applicable to criminal claims (§ 32 ZPO) if there is a connection to Germany. It is significantly more difficult to justify claims under the partnership agreement in the USA. In addition, there are often jurisdiction clauses in the contracts.

Even if a German court has jurisdiction, practical obstacles remain:

Four hurdles in the German legal system

1. Duration

The lawsuit must be served in the USA under the Hague Convention on Service of Process. This takes months, according to experience.

2. Expert report required

The German court will often have to apply US law, for example regarding the rights and obligations of the general partner. This requires expert legal opinions on foreign law.

3. Documents from the opposing side

The plaintiff must largely substantiate his argument with his own documents. However, the crucial documents are in the opposing party's possession.

4. Own procedure necessary

A German judgment is not automatically enforceable in the USA. It must be recognized there in a separate procedure.

What a procedure in the USA offers TSO investors

A procedure at the headquarters of the project companies offers four advantages, which I will discuss in the following articles:

Four advantages of procedures in the USA

1. Evidence gathering (Discovery)

Comprehensive submission of documents, testimony under oath, and requests for information from third parties, particularly banks. This makes it possible to understand where investor funds have gone.

2. Execution

Court orders and judgments against the project companies are directly enforceable in the judicial state, without a preliminary recognition procedure.

3. Compensation for damages

U.S. law, under certain conditions, recognizes legal consequences that are different from German law, such as punitive damages.

4. Costs

In the USA, in principle, each party bears its own legal costs. The risk of having to pay for the lawyers of the opposing side is thus generally eliminated. Additionally, (partially) performance-based remuneration models are permissible.

Case-by-case approach instead of a general rule

Whether and where a lawsuit is appropriate depends on the individual case. The relevant factors are the participation structure, the provisions in the Partnership Agreement, any jurisdictional or arbitration clauses, and the current deadlines.

There is no one-size-fits-all answer. However, I would advise any TSO investor to start with the question of the jurisdiction and not the end.

Image source: studio v-zwoelf

TSO investors

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I file a lawsuit as a TSO investor in the USA?

Basically, yes. Foreign investors can sue in US courts just like domestic investors. Which court is competent depends on the location of the companies and the provisions in the Partnership Agreement.

Isn't a lawsuit in Germany easier?

For the investor initially, perhaps. However, German courts have limited jurisdiction over US companies, and a German judgment must first be recognized in the USA in a separate proceeding.
Are there any claims in my case? This can only be assessed after examining the documents, in particular the Partnership Agreement, the reports and the correspondence.

Do I need a US lawyer?

Yes, for a lawsuit in a US court. It is helpful if this lawyer also knows German law and can communicate with you in German.

About the author

Carl Christian Thier LL.M., Esq. He is a lawyer in Germany and an attorney at law in New York. He advises German clients on German-American legal matters, particularly in the areas of business and inheritance law, and represents German investors in the enforcement of their rights in the USA. 

Contact

Urban Thier Federer Attorneys at Law – Germany/USA
Carl Christian Thier, Esq., Attorney at Law, New York – Germany
Honorary Consul Austria

Please briefly and confidentially describe your case. We will contact you promptly with a clear proposal for the next steps.

Note: This blog/article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The information presented in the blog/article does not replace the need to seek legal advice from a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction regarding your specific case. You should not rely on any statements made in this article. No part of this website creates an attorney-client relationship. We cannot guarantee that the information published is accurate, complete, or up-to-date.